top of page

Breast Cancer Risk, Prevention, Dense Breasts, and HRT: What Women Should Know

14 minutes ago
4 min read

Walk on the trail

When I speak with breast cancer survivors, I often hear about the stress they were experiencing before their diagnosis: a divorce, a family illness, or intense struggles with a hurting child they could not help. These conversations have shaped how I think about breast cancer risk and the many factors that can contribute to it.


About 20% of breast cancer is inherited. Other contributing factors include excess alcohol, methylation dysfunction, toxin exposure, and stress.


The way one PhD biochemist put it: “It is the stress we did not choose and have no control over.” Starting a menopause clinic is stressful, but it is a stress I chose and love—and one I could stop at any time. When a family member gets sick, that is a stress I have no control over, so I have to be especially careful to manage my stress levels.


Managing stress is always important. Because of what I hear from survivors, I always check cortisol levels to see where women are. The majority of women in my practice have burned through their cortisol and no longer have levels adequate for protection.


Lifestyle and Breast Cancer Prevention

Stress is one part of the picture. There are also lifestyle factors we can work on.


Breastfeeding is shown to be protective, and a Mediterranean, low-inflammation diet is protective. Exercise is the BEST way to prevent breast cancer and breast cancer recurrence—even a 30-minute walk most days. Maintaining an optimal body weight is important, too. Being overweight is a risk factor that can be modified, so if you are at risk for breast cancer, maintain a healthy weight and stay away from alcohol. Smoking is also a risk factor, and there is evidence of increased risk with secondhand smoke exposure.


Food choices matter as well. Why is high-fructose corn syrup so concerning? It is the only “sugar” that does not require insulin to get into the cell, which should terrify anyone. It is not natural at all. Beet and cane sugar are safer, but limit the quantity. Stay away from high-fructose corn syrup, seed oils, and anything processed. Sugar is a risk factor, especially high-fructose corn syrup.


I also consider factors such as endocrine-disrupting chemicals, cholesterol, vitamin D, insulin, and methylation. Toxins from endocrine-disrupting chemicals are associated with increased breast cancer risk in many studies. These include bisphenol A (BPA), parabens, phthalates, and pesticides. High cholesterol is associated with breast cancer due to cholesterol metabolites, which vitamin D can help decrease. Vitamin D deficiency is associated with breast cancer; my goal is 55–80 ng/mL. Elevated insulin and insulin resistance have been shown to increase the risk of multiple cancers and have been linked to breast cancer. Obesity is also associated with increased risk.


Methylation dysfunction can lead to increased dangerous estrogen metabolites. That is one reason estrogen metabolism testing is my new favorite test.


Breast Cancer Screening and Dense Breasts

Along with lifestyle and risk factors, screening is an important part of breast health. I recommend annual mammograms. Mammography has become much more sensitive over the years, but dense breast tissue can make mammograms a bit harder to interpret. Bioidentical hormones can increase breast density, so we should keep that in mind and remain diligent with breast exams and mammograms.


If you are concerned about radiation exposure, you can consider alternating mammograms with thermography. I would want to discuss this with you so you can make an informed decision. MRI is the more definitive imaging modality if your mammogram is inconclusive or if there are still concerns after a normal mammogram. Ultrasound does not detect microcalcifications, so it is not an adequate screening method.


For some women with invasive breast cancer, the discussion may also include surgery. Some more conservative physicians recommend bilateral mastectomy with any breast cancer diagnosis given the risk of recurrence in the other breast.


Does HRT Cause Breast Cancer?

Questions about screening and breast density often lead to questions about HRT. The HRT that was found to increase breast cancer risk is synthetic progestins—not bioidentical progesterone—which are found in birth control pills and IUDs. Oral birth control has been linked to breast cancer, particularly progestins. Progesterone, not progestins, has been shown to decrease the risk of breast cancer.


It amazes me how cavalier physicians can be about birth control but then they are afraid to give women HRT. I digress.


If you are at risk for breast cancer, that does not mean you cannot have HRT. In fact, HRT may be protective with proper dosing. Dr. Manders and I love prescribing HRT when appropriate, but we check levels because there is no safety evidence for hormones given at very high doses, which can occur when levels are not being monitored.


Estrogen Metabolism Testing

Methylation dysfunction can lead to increased dangerous estrogen metabolites, which is why I’m especially interested in understanding how women metabolize estrogen. My new favorite test is a urine hormone-metabolite test. I recommend it for all my patients on HRT, especially those known to be at increased risk of breast cancer. It shows how you metabolize estrogens, including whether you metabolize them toward the more concerning pathways. If you metabolize toward the more dangerous estrogen metabolites, we can do something about it.


The basic estrogen-metabolism test costs $225 and can be done at home by collecting a simple urine sample. Our patients can let us know if they would like to test their estrogen metabolism. This is a test every woman should consider.


Breast cancer risk, prevention, screening, and hormone decisions are personal. At Dragonfly Menopause Care, Dr. Manders and I look at the whole picture with each woman, including her history, lifestyle, breast screening, hormone levels, and estrogen metabolism. If you have questions about your own risk or want to discuss your options, we are here to help.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page