Beyond Statins: Thoughtful Alternatives for Managing Cholesterol in Midlife

Statins are the most prescribed class of medications in the U.S.—and for many, they may offer life-saving protection against cardiovascular disease. I have deep respect for my allopathic colleagues who prescribe them based on decades of research and clinical experience. At the same time, my training and growing interest in functional medicine have led me to approach cholesterol and heart health with a broader, more nuanced lens.

I believe there’s more than one side to the statin story. Not everyone who is prescribed a statin truly needs one. And for those who can’t tolerate them—or simply want to understand their options—there are alternatives.

This blog is my attempt to help you sort through:

• What works and what doesn’t

• Where the controversy comes from

• And how to approach your cholesterol numbers in a way that supports your whole health, not just a lab value

  
  

Cholesterol Is Not the Enemy

Before we jump into medications and supplements, it’s important to understand what cholesterol actually does in your body. It plays a vital role in:

• Hormone production – including estrogen, progesterone, testosterone, and cortisol

• Vitamin D synthesis – critical for bone, immune, and mood health

• Cell structure – cholesterol is part of every cell membrane

• Nerve function – it protects the myelin sheath for healthy nerve signaling

• Brain health – supports cognition and neurotransmitter balance

  
  

As cardiologist Dr. Aseem Malhotra points out, the benefits of statins may have more to do with their anti-inflammatory and insulin-sensitizing effects than with cholesterol-lowering alone (interestingly, as I explain in my blog about estrogen and heart health, the anti-inflammatory effects of estradiol are how it decreases risk of heart disease). Cholesterol itself is not inherently dangerous—it’s just one part of a much bigger picture.

So... What Are the Alternatives?

Statins are very effective at lowering LDL cholesterol and reducing cardiovascular events in high-risk individuals. But not everyone is high risk. For many women in midlife, especially those without known heart disease, the decision to start a statin should be informed, personalized, and based on more than a single number.

Here are the alternative strategies we may consider:

1. Red Yeast Rice

This supplement contains monacolin K, which is chemically identical to the statin drug lovastatin. It’s effective—but it can also cause the same muscle pain and liver enzyme changes.

• Typical dose: 1.2 grams daily

• Monitoring: Liver function and muscle symptoms should be tracked

It's natural, but not necessarily gentler or safer.

2. Berberine

A plant-based compound that improves LDL cholesterol, triglycerides, and insulin sensitivity. Helpful for women with metabolic syndrome or insulin resistance.

• Dose: 500 mg, 2–3 times daily

• Duration studied: Up to 2 years

  
  

3. Fish Oil (Omega-3s)

Especially effective at lowering triglycerides. Prescription forms (Lovaza, Omtryg) are standardized and FDA-approved. Over-the-counter supplements are often weaker and require higher doses.

• Effective dose: at least 3–4 grams EPA/DHA daily

• Triglyceride reduction: 20%–50%, depending on baseline

• 
  

4. Niacin (Vitamin B3)

Can lower LDL and triglycerides while increasing HDL. Not often used today due to limited benefit on cardiovascular outcomes in major trials—but may still be useful for specific lipid patterns.

• Prescription dose: 1–2 grams daily

• Side effects: Flushing, especially with hot drinks

  
  

5. CoQ10

Often used to ease statin-induced muscle pain. Evidence is conflicting—some studies show benefit, others do not.

• Typical dose: 100–300 mg daily, divided

• Bottom line: Safe to try, but not a guaranteed fix

  
  

6. Hormone Therapy (HRT)

Oral estrogen can improve lipid profiles—but because it’s processed through the liver, it may increase clotting risks (among other potential effects). I do not prescribe oral estrogen for this reason.

Instead, I use transdermal estrogen, which avoids liver metabolism and has a better safety profile. While it doesn’t improve cholesterol quite as much, it can support metabolic and cardiovascular health when used appropriately.

7. CT Calcium Scoring: Looking Beyond the Numbers

One tool I often use to help patients make more confident decisions is a coronary artery calcium (CAC) score. This low-dose CT scan looks for calcified plaque in the arteries and gives us direct evidence of heart disease—or reassurance if no disease is present.

• A score of zero usually means low short-term risk, and medications may be avoidable

• A higher score (>100-400) can clarify when statins or other therapies may be beneficial

This approach helps us move from generic guidelines to personalized, evidence-based decisions.

8. And Most Importantly: Lifestyle Is the Foundation

Supplements and medications can help—but lifestyle is where the real change happens. If you want to improve cholesterol, reduce inflammation, and support heart health, this is where we start:

• Nutrition: Mediterranean-style or low-carb whole food diets support healthy lipid profiles

• Strength training: Especially important for insulin sensitivity and long-term cardiovascular health

• Movement and walking: Improves triglycerides and vascular function

• Sleep, stress, and alcohol moderation: Often overlooked but essential for lipid and metabolic health

These daily habits are powerful medicine—and they work.

Final Thoughts

Not everyone who is on a statin needs to be. And not every alternative is a magic bullet. But if you’re looking for a more nuanced conversation—one that considers your symptoms, risks, hormone status, calcium score, and lifestyle—then you're in the right place.

You deserve care that goes beyond a prescription pad. Let’s create a plan that works with your body, your values, and your long-term goals.

Want to better understand your cholesterol and your options?

Schedule your personalized consult online or call (952) 522-4565. I would love to help you feel empowered in your care. You have choices but they require education and understanding so that you can make the most informed decision for you.

Warmly,

Dr. Christa Waymire

Board-Certified Family Physician & Menopause Specialist

Dragonfly Menopause Care – Chanhassen, MN & via Zoom throughout Minnesota